46% emptied the whole pot first time, and that is the number behind this week's pensions plan
What happened
On 3 November 2026, the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) launched two consultations on how pensions should work when people actually retire. The Minister for Pensions, Torsten Bell, announced them while speaking at the Association of British Insurers Long-Term Savings Conference. The first is called Guided Retirement. It is published jointly with the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Pensions Regulator, and it asks how "default pensions" should work in practice. The idea is that pension schemes would be required to provide a default pension for savers approaching retirement, so people get the option of a stable income for life without having to become investment experts overnight. The second is on Retirement Collective Pension Schemes, or RCPS, and covers draft regulations that would let these schemes be used as a default pension under Guided Retirement. The government also published its response to an earlier policy consultation on RCPS on the same day. The Guided Retirement consultation runs from 3 November 2026 to 22 December 2026, and sets out initial proposals for secondary legislation under the Pension Schemes Act 2026. It was developed by DWP, HM Treasury, the FCA and the Pensions Regulator together. The government says around 17 million private sector workers currently saving into a pension would be given the option of an income in retirement.
Why this matters
To understand this, you need to know about two kinds of pension. The old style is called Defined Benefit, or DB. You worked, and at the end you were promised an income for life, often rising with the cost of living. Most public sector pensions still work roughly like this. The newer style is Defined Contribution, or DC. You and your employer pay money in, it gets invested, and at the end you have a pot of money. What happens next is up to you. DWP's point is that over the last 30 years, the vast majority of private sector DB schemes have closed. Automatic enrolment has been a real success at getting people saving: nine in ten eligible private sector workers now save into a pension, up from four in ten in 2012. But almost all of them are saving into DC schemes. So millions of people are heading for retirement with a pot, not a pension. And a pot raises a question nobody has really equipped them to answer: how much can I take out each year without running out of money before I run out of life? That question is genuinely hard. It depends on how long you live, which you cannot know, and on investment returns, which you cannot control. As Therese Chambers, executive director at the FCA, put it: "People should not have to navigate complex pension decisions alone."
What the evidence actually says
The most revealing figure in the announcement is this one: in 2025/26, around 46% of first-time pension pot accesses involved the pot being fully withdrawn. Nearly half of people touching their pension for the first time emptied it. That deserves careful reading. Many of those pots will have been small - someone with £3,000 from an old job may sensibly take the lot. So this is not evidence that half the country is recklessly cashing in their life savings. But it does show how little the current system guides people, and the government argues it reveals a real risk: people outliving their money. DWP notes this is not only a UK problem, pointing to other countries including Australia where individuals face similar risk and fear in retirement. It is worth being straight about what the two consultations are and are not. They are consultations. The Guided Retirement one closes on 22 December 2026 and seeks views on proposals for secondary legislation. Nothing is being imposed this month. Retirement Collective Pension Schemes work by pooling risk between members. In simple terms, instead of each person privately guessing how long they will live, the scheme manages that across a group, which can deliver a steadier income. The trade-off, and it is a real one, is that an income from a collective scheme is not guaranteed in the way a traditional DB promise was. It can be adjusted if the scheme's finances require it. DWP describes RCPS as providing "stability and growth" and a "fully managed pension people can rely on for life" - stability is not the same as a cast-iron guarantee, and savers should understand that difference. The government is also clear that choice remains. Savers who want a different option "will always be free to choose". A default is a path of least resistance, not a compulsion. Richard Knox of the Pensions Regulator added that "well-designed default options at retirement will help people navigate these complex and important financial decisions" - with the weight on "well-designed", which is exactly what the consultation is for.
Practical advice
Nothing changes for you this week. But a few things are worth doing anyway. Find out what you actually have. Most people have several old pensions from different jobs. The free government-backed Pension Tracing Service can help you find lost ones, and the MoneyHelper service, also government-backed and free, can explain the options in plain English. Check your State Pension forecast on GOV.UK. It is the foundation that everything else sits on top of, and knowing the number changes how you think about the rest. If you are within a few years of retiring, this is the moment to get guidance rather than guess. Pension Wise, delivered through MoneyHelper, offers free appointments for people aged 50 and over with a DC pension. Free, impartial, and not trying to sell you anything. Be cautious about taking a whole pot at once. Beyond the tax-free element, withdrawals are usually taxable, and taking a large sum in one year can push you into a higher tax band unnecessarily. It can also affect means-tested benefits. And be very alert to pension scams. Any unexpected contact offering a free pension review, an unusual investment or early access to your pension before 55 should be treated as a scam until proven otherwise. The FCA's ScamSmart service lets you check. If you work in pensions or run a scheme, the consultation is open until 22 December 2026, and the Pensions Regulator has explicitly asked schemes to engage with it.
What to know
DWP launched two consultations on 3 November 2026: Guided Retirement, published with the FCA and the Pensions Regulator, and one on draft regulations for Retirement Collective Pension Schemes. Guided Retirement closes on 22 December 2026. The plan would require schemes to offer a default pension for savers approaching retirement, giving around 17 million private sector workers the option of an income for life rather than just a pot of money. The key statistic: around 46% of first-time pension pot accesses in 2025/26 involved full withdrawal. Many of those pots were small, but it shows how little the current system guides people. Collective schemes pool risk to give a steadier income, but that income is not guaranteed in the way old final-salary promises were. Choice is retained throughout. Nothing changes yet. Meanwhile: trace old pensions free, check your State Pension forecast, and if you are 50 or over use free Pension Wise guidance before making any decision. Sources: Department for Work and Pensions, "New plans 'resurrect' genuine pensions for millions of private sector workers", 3 November 2026, https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-plans-resurrect-genuine-pensions-for-millions-of-private-sector-workers; MoneyHelper, "Pension Wise", accessed 4 November 2026, https://www.moneyhelper.org.uk/en/pensions-and-retirement/pension-wise; GOV.UK, "Check your State Pension forecast", accessed 4 November 2026, https://www.gov.uk/check-state-pension This article is for general information and is not legal, financial or medical advice. For questions about your own health or medicines, speak to a doctor, pharmacist or other qualified healthcare professional.
Related articles
Eight new water councils, and a deadline of the end of this year to shape them
On 5 November 2026, the government announced that eight new regional water councils will be set up in England, giving local leaders a formal say over billions o…
86,890 young people, and a rule that they can no longer be called intentionally homeless
On 5 November 2026, at the start of Care Leavers Month, the government published the Care Leaver Homelessness Reduction Action Plan. The plan starts from a sim…
No badgers culled in 2026, and a target year of 2038
On Thursday 5 November 2026, the government formally adopted a long-term plan to wipe out bovine tuberculosis in England by 2038. Bovine TB is a disease of cat…