Ofsted will trial a new way of handling complaints from schools
What happened
Ofsted has announced that it will pilot a new complaints process for schools during the 2026-27 academic year. The plan was set out by Ofsted's Chief Inspector, Martyn Oliver, in a letter to Parliament's education committee, and reported on 8 September 2026. Under the current system, a school unhappy with an inspection can complain to Ofsted. If it is unhappy with how that complaint was handled, it can go to the Independent Complaints Adjudication Service for Ofsted, known as ICASO. But ICASO looks only at the handling of the complaint. It cannot overturn an inspection grade. The pilot would go further. Schools would be able to ask for a review of both how Ofsted handled their complaint and "whether the outcome of their complaint was reasonable, including where aspects were linked to inspection findings". An independent panel would carry out that review. The details of how the panel would be made up have not yet been set out. Mr Oliver said the change "will add greater independent oversight to the process". The reaction from school leaders was cool. Julia Waters, the sister of headteacher Ruth Perry, said: "It's barely an improvement... Ofsted would still mark their own homework." Paul Whiteman of the National Association of Head Teachers said "the lack of meaningful independence fails to inspire confidence". Andy Jordan of the Association of School and College Leaders said "school leaders will continue to remain aggrieved".
Why this matters
This announcement sits in a long and painful context. Ruth Perry was a headteacher in Reading who took her own life in 2023 while awaiting the publication of an Ofsted report. A coroner concluded that the inspection had contributed to her death. Her family have campaigned for change since. An independent review by Dame Christine Gilbert recommended external oversight with the power to reopen inspection judgements. That is the specific point at issue here. The pilot Ofsted has announced stops short of giving an outside body the power to change a grade. Whether that gap matters is the question school leaders are raising. For parents, this is less abstract than it might seem. Ofsted reports shape school reputations, admissions, staff recruitment and, in some cases, whether a school is forced to change hands. If the accuracy of those judgements cannot be independently challenged, the reports carry a weight the process may not fully support. There is also a workforce dimension. Julia Waters has said she has heard from headteachers inspected under the new framework who felt suicidal afterwards. Recruiting and keeping headteachers is already difficult.
What the evidence actually says
It is important to be accurate about what has and has not been announced. This is a pilot, not a permanent change. It runs during the 2026-27 academic year. The composition and powers of the independent panel have not been published. That is why the responses have been cautious rather than either welcoming or hostile - there is not yet enough detail to judge. The key unresolved point is whether the panel can change an inspection outcome, or only comment on whether Ofsted's handling was reasonable. On the information published so far, the panel reviews whether the outcome of a complaint was reasonable, which is not the same as being able to overturn a grade. There is also relevant work still to come. An independent assessment of the new inspection framework by IFF Research is expected this autumn, with full findings in 2027. That will provide evidence about how the new framework is actually landing in schools, which this announcement does not. Ofsted, for its part, points to other changes it has made, including mental health awareness training for inspectors and a more collaborative approach during inspections. The honest summary is that this is a step, that its size is not yet clear, and that the people most affected do not currently think it is large enough.
Practical advice
If you are a parent, remember that an Ofsted grade is a snapshot taken on particular days by particular people. It is useful information, not a complete picture. Read the report itself rather than only the headline judgement. The text usually tells you far more about what a school is actually like. Visit if you can. Ask to speak to pupils, not just staff. How children talk about their school tells you a great deal. If you have a concern about your child's school, the order matters: raise it with the school first, then the governing body or trust, then Ofsted or the Department for Education. Ofsted does not investigate individual complaints about a school on a parent's behalf, though it does use what parents say as information for future inspections. Parent View, Ofsted's online questionnaire, is open all year, not only during an inspection. If you work in a school and an inspection has affected your mental health, please do not sit with it. Education Support runs a free, confidential helpline for education staff across the UK, and your union will also have support available. If you are in crisis, the Samaritans can be reached free on 116 123 at any hour.
What to know
Ofsted will pilot a new complaints process during the 2026-27 academic year, allowing schools to ask an independent panel to review both how a complaint was handled and whether its outcome was reasonable. Details of the panel's membership and powers have not been published, and it appears not to have the power to overturn inspection grades outright. School leaders' organisations and Ruth Perry's family have described the change as insufficient, arguing it lacks meaningful independence. An independent assessment of Ofsted's new inspection framework by IFF Research is due this autumn, with full findings in 2027. Sources: Schools Week, "Ofsted to pilot new complaints process to bring 'greater independent oversight'", 8 September 2026, https://schoolsweek.co.uk/ofsted-to-pilot-new-complaints-process-to-bring-greater-independent-oversight/ ; Schools Week, "Powell wants 'more supportive and understanding' school accountability system", 3 September 2026, https://schoolsweek.co.uk/powell-wants-more-supportive-and-understanding-school-accountability-system/ This article is for general information about education policy and does not replace advice from a doctor, pharmacist or other qualified healthcare professional. If you are struggling with your mental health, please speak to your GP, or contact the Samaritans free on 116 123 at any time.
Related articles
One in 20 young people say they have no close friends at all
A report published on 1 September 2026 by the Institute for Public Policy Research has found that young people in England are dramatically more isolated than th…
England went up in the international school rankings. Most countries went down
The results of PISA 2025 were published on 8 September 2026, and for England they were unusually good news. PISA stands for the Programme for International Stu…
Half of headteachers have dealt with pupil photos being misused
Nearly half of headteachers in the UK have had to deal with photographs of their pupils being misused. That finding comes from a survey of 500 UK headteachers…